is the best way to manage your money. Go there now »

Sign up or log in to mint.com

The Pros and Cons of Online Banks

Share This

Banks have always been viewed as the safest place to park your money but, in the wake of the financial crisis, this perception has changed. Not only have people’s confidence in the stability of banks been shattered by collapse of WaMu, etc., but ever increasing bank fees and executive payouts have engendered distrust. On a more practical level, there are just fewer banks to go around. Many banks have either folded or been swallowed up by larger financial institutions, forcing people to look around for more options.

Bank online

Online banking is a relatively recent phenomenon that has become increasingly popular as consumers become more comfortable with doing the majority of their activities — from shopping for books or music to booking their airline tickets — in the cloud. Most major banks offer online services today, which provide 24/7 access to your accounts and advanced services such as the ability to pay bills online. There are even Internet-only banks such as First Internet Bank of Indiana or Smartypig that, because they don’t have the overhead of physical infrastructure, can offer substantially higher interest rates on savings accounts. Smartypig pays an APY of 2.75%. Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of online banks.

Pros

  1. They tend to offer higher interest rates than local banks due to lower overhead costs such as paper mail, lease and other real estate expenses.
  2. Some banks offer customer service available 24/7 or till late evening hours.
  3. You can quickly initiate transactions online such as a transfer, withdrawal request or a bill payment in a matter of minutes.
  4. Most paperwork can be filled out on the computer and transmitted electronically.
  5. You can set up alerts so the bank will let you know when your balance is low.
  6. Less paper mail such as bank statements and utility bills will decrease the amount of paper trail left behind for identity thieves.
  7. No Fees- The majority of online banks do not charge fees. HSBC for example has no monthly fees and no minimum balance requirement for their online savings account.

Cons

  1. Limited Access – you can’t just drop off your deposit like you would at a local bank. It must be mailed or transferred from another account.
  2. At some online banks, the customer doesn’t have the opportunity to get to know the staff. Calls are often handled through a random system where you will get to speak to different customer representatives every time you call for an issue.
  3. Make sure you select a bank with many ATM’s available, otherwise you will end up paying fees for using machines not part of the bank.
  4. It takes longer to clear a deposit.
  5. Paperwork requiring signatures has to be done through mail, taking longer to process.
  6. Your bank’s website can go down, limiting access to accounts temporarily

Just to give you an idea of the services online banks offer, HSBC has an online savings account with an interest rate of 1.85%. Wachovia has several online services available in addition to online banking such as bill pay, brokerage and retirement accounts. Bank of Internet has an online interest checking account that pays an APY of 1.30% and a high yield savings with an APY of 2%. At the time this article was written, national overnight averages for savings accounts were of .77% for interest checking accounts and 1.39% for a savings.

Although some consumers have remained skeptical about doing their banking online, the majority have been easily seduced by the ready access to balances and the ease with which these services categorize transactions. The advancements in technology and privacy protection have also pushed more people to take the leap.

Bank locally

On the other hand, with distrust in the banking industry at a fever pitch, some people are taking solace in the old-fashioned comfort that can be found in a local brick and mortar bank where you know the teller by name and she remembers yours. Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of local bank accounts.

Pros

  1. Easy access – you can just drop off by your local branch to make deposits or get cash withdrawals.
  2. Familiarity – by becoming a regular customer, you get familiar with staff, getting to know some on a first name basis.
  3. Quick access to cashier’s and certified checks.

Cons

  1. Limited hours of operation – At most banks, after 4 or 5 pm you can’t get a representative to help you – you’d have to wait till the next day.
  2. Interest rates tend to be on the low end in comparison to online banking.
  3. More opportunity to spend your money because it is so easy to access it.

With the banking industry in a state of reorganization, there’s never been a better time to be a customer. All banks, whether an established brick and mortar institution or a scrappy newcomer that only exists in cyberspace are scrambling to regain your trust. Of course you want the best interest rate you can get but you’ll also want to consider things like ease of access to your money, any fees that may be associated with your accounts, and the security and stability of the financial institution in question Decide what options you would like to have and what you can do without when considering the pros and cons of either method of banking. And it doesn’t have to be an either/or decision. The best approach if you decide to open an online account is preferably to keep your local bank account open, this will enable you to have the access you need to some of your cash if an emergency arises.

11 Comments so far

leave a comment
  1. I use Charles Swab (Internet only) bank and love it. Everything is free including all ATMs worldwide. Charles Shwab does not charge you a fee to use ATMs and when the third party bank/ATM charges you a fee, Charles Swab pays you that fee back in your monthly statement. I never have to worry about going somewhere where my bank does not have an ATM because I can literally use any ATM worldwide. There is no minimum balance or fee to use this service at all. In fact everything is free including postage paid deposit envelopes!

  2. There really are no “Cons” to an online bank if you are functioning in the modern world. Who goes to the bank to make deposits? I guess if you have a small business that makes sense but if you have a job, chances are you have direct deposit. I think my grandmother was the last person to have a personal relationship with the teller. Taking longer to clear a deposit may be an issue if you live payday to payday. I have an online bank account and thus far my signature has not been required on any paperwork, but I haven’t taken out any loans either. I don’t find the pro’s of having a local bank all that enticing because I use credit and debit cards for nearly everything. My barber is one of the last holdouts, he only takes cash or check. I also have a local bank so I can do a realistic comparison and unless you own a small business that handles a lot of cash or checks I don’t see any real advantage to one type of bank over the other, but that’s just me.

  3. I don’t know if “Familiarity” is a pro to a local bank anymore. I have several friends that just graduated from college and took jobs as tellers in banks. The pay is only around $9/hr. All of them are actively seeking other jobs and it seems as if turnover occurs at the banks at pretty high rate. Most of the loan officers are even still in there mid-twenties and don’t stick around long. Bank tellers seem to have just become “cashiers” at a bank, and making about the same wage as a Wal*Mart cashier. I guess Wells Fargo looks better on a resume than Wal*Mart though.

  4. Now that I look into it, the Schwab savings account would seem to be a good competitor with CapOne on those terms (since it reimburses ATM fees while CapOne doesn’t). It’s only 0.05% APY less, too. Chinese ATMs don’t seem to charge fees, so perhaps I’m fine for now.

  5. Ana Gonzalez Ribeiro

    Just to keep everyone updated on the current rates, HSBC has an online savings account rate of 1.55% and Bank of Internet has a high yield savings rate of 2.06%. The current online interest checking APY is still 1.30%

  6. I use Wells Fargo for both personally banking and online banking. I realize that this does not necessarily fit into the categories online bank or local bank, but Wells Fargo does offer a great balance between the two. With locations all over the US I am rarely without the services of a local branch and with online banking (and now mobile banking – a key new feature now being provided on almost all smart-phone carriers) I have 24/7 access to all of my accounts (credit, savings, checking, brokerage and loans.) There is no way I would use a bank that did not have both functions.

  7. A TWC customer for a year and I get surveyed and I figured I would give a survey to the members of payee services that I distibute funds too as the bankteller. THere’s five questions it’s a rating system and these are the questions that we may ask in the following month to the members.
    1. Overall on a scale of one to five. Five being very satisifed, Four being satisified, Three is nuetral, two unsatisfied, and one very unsatisified, how satisfied were you with the last teller that you just experienced.
    2. While talking with the last teller you spoke with how well was her/his knowledge or patience with your transaction did it meet your value and fair standards?
    3. While talking with the very last teller that you experienced would you either prefer counting of your money or distributing the right amount is all right too?
    4. Is there anything that you might add, again, with the last teller that you did your business or money transaction with?
    5.If you were issued a FDR limited edition bank card and were able to use it at most ATM’s (i.e. JPM) would you be willing to pay transaction fee?

  8. Very good article. In fact, not only online banking gets more popular, online personal finance service also gradually replaces the banks:

    http://www.wealthalchemist.com/Blog/2009/01/personal-finance-websites-replace-banks/

    MINT is actually a good example!

  9. Great article Ana. I tend to prefer online banking, but hey, that’s just me. I have many friends who don’t trust using online banking, which I think is kind of unfair of them to say. Online banks these days are very secure.

    Just Tweeted this as well! :)

  10. Some online banks have a deposit at home feature where you can scan a check into your account, thereby knocking that con off the list. USAA is one such bank.

  11. John Doe

    I want to open account with online banks with good APY rate and narrowed down to CapOne (addl benefits for being a Costco member), EverBank and Ally. Can anyone suggest based on their past experiences & market knowledge about which one is the best to go for?

Leave a Comment

How Mint Can Help

See Where You Spend

Mint.com auto-categorizes all of your transactions so you’ll always know where your money goes. Find out more »