is the best way to manage your money. Go there now »

Sign up or log in to mint.com

How to Invest in Gold the Right Way

Share This

Photo: Mykl Roventine

The expression “as good as gold” suggests that gold is something of a sure thing when it comes to investments. But, while gold and other commodities remain a solid investment choice, when it comes to investing there’s no such thing as a sure thing. The trick to investing in gold is knowing the difference between gold and other asset classes; stocks, bonds, real-estate, even cold hard cash.

Putting a Value on Gold

Let’s start with its value or, as with so many things, its perceived value. Valuing gold is a tricky thing. Without earnings or cash flow (which is the most commonly used metric in valuing a company and its stock) it can be tough to identify the appropriate valuation of gold. How many dollars should an ounce of gold be worth? The spot price is simply dependent on the market forces of buyers and sellers; therefore, for the price to increase, you need more buyers than sellers. So rather than speculating, consider the following approach.

Gold as Insurance

Don’t trade gold. Moving in and out of a gold position, like many do with stocks is not a smart strategy. Gold, historically, is very volatile and has erratic movements in its spot price. Attempting to guess short-term price movements is near impossible.

The right way to view gold is as insurance. The beautiful thing about gold is that it is very tough to manipulate its price, especially over time. Stocks, bonds, and even currencies can be manipulated by political powers through monetary policy and government action. Gold will keep its value through a wide range of economic scenarios which is one reason it is so appealing during an economic downturn such as the one we are currently suffering through. As such, it can be held in order to insure against risks to your other assets. So, what are the risks?

The number one risk that you should be prepared for is the loss of purchasing power of your currency. Typically this happens whenever the government attempts to manipulate the economy in some way. The latest attempt to “fix” the struggling economy has only delayed the inevitable by increasing the national debt. The influx of cash from the economic stimulus package needs to be paid for somehow. And the usual result of this kind of spending spree is a debasement of the currency and/or inflation. When inflation occurs, your dollars are worth less. Put in layman’s terms, it is akin to attempting to dig yourself out of a hole. More debt creation will not result in getting us out of debt. So how can you protect yourself against this risk? You need insurance.

Now, just like you should not put all your eggs in one basket for a specific stock, you should not be betting the farm on an increase in the price of gold either. Liquidating all of your assets and buying gold would be a little extreme. Instead, insure your assets and your purchasing power by allocating a percentage of your assets in precious metals such as gold. Most experts recommend allocating somewhere in the range of 10%-30% of your assets. If you’re new to the gold game, start with 10%.

How to Buy and Own Gold

Ain’t nothing like the real thing baby. Part of your gold allocation should be in real, physical gold that is in your possession. You can purchase gold coins or bullion from precious metal dealers. Obviously, you will need to give good thought to where and how you will store your gold and protect it from theft or loss. Sorry, Fort Knox is not an option.

You can also consider buying ETFs that attempt to track the spot price of gold. You can purchase these ETFs (such as GLD) like any other stock through your brokerage account.

Lastly, you can consider creating an account with a company like GoldMoney. GoldMoney allows you to deposit cash and keep your account balance in gold. When you wish to withdrawal your funds, you will then transfer your money back into cash based on the spot price of gold at that time.

If you’re concerned that the price of gold has already risen considerably over the previous years (which it has), consider dollar cost averaging into the appropriate size position that you wish to hold. Buy a fixed number of gold coins each month or every couple months. This will help prevent buying all of your gold at one time which might be at a relatively high price.

Speculating on the price of gold can be as risky as any other form of investment. Instead, use it as a hedge against inflation and a way to gain additional diversification. But don’t take my word for it. As with any investment be sure to do your own research.

For more of Kevin’s writing, visit personal finance blog 20smoney.com.

Related Videos

17 Comments so far

leave a comment
  1. I’m really happy to see a story on gold. It’s a really hot topic right now and I think a lot of people who don’t understand it can get burned. I have a couple quibbles with a few of your points.

    You’re going to get bad pricing when you go to buy physical gold and REALLY bad pricing when you go to sell it. Owning GLD (which represents about 1/10th of an ounce of bullion that they physically have) is a much easier way to own it.

    Also, 30% of your portfolio in gold is extremely high. That would be a really fringe expert who recommends that high an allocation.

  2. why cant i connect my goldmoney account to mint???

    • Here’s another vote for allowing digital precious metals currencies (GoldMoney, eGold, etc.) as assets in Mint.com

  3. humanfly

    I suspect that an expert would suggest more like a 5% metals target, with maybe a cap of 10% during more normal economic times. So you acquire your target of 5% of your entire portfolio and maybe throw a bit of silver and platinum in the mix, and if it grows to 10% of your portfolio, rebalance. I think you’ve missed much of the profit available through gold, one question is how much further will the dollar devalue, gold only has to hold it’s value to be better than cash. I suspect that now is would be a better time to acquire platinum to hold for the long term, since it’s at a great discount; gold is off it’s historical peak when you factor in inflation but I think you’re getting a much better value by getting platinum or maybe a bit of silver.

    I’m no expert, but putting 10 to 30% of your worth into one thing breaks the rule of diversity.

  4. Andrew

    What is the return on your investment if you have to pay to buy, sell and store your investment. Physical gold will be great to have if we end up in a mad max style distopian future, but otherwise, wouldn’t an ETF make more sense, than the actual commodity.

    One ETF you can look at if you think that gold is over valued is DZZ. It is a double short index. If the value of gold goes down, it goes up.

  5. Gold is an absurd recommendation for an American! Even at normal prices, gold has no use except as a “store of value,” because you’ll really only need gold as “insurance” if society falls apart, and in that case, you’d be better served investing in something actually useful, like oil, and/or something that actually earns income while you’re waiting for society to collapse, like real estate. And with gold prices ALREADY at all-time highs, this article is basically recommending that people buy into the top of what is only the most recent in a series of gold bubbles. Remember, gold earns nothing, is essentially useless, and even costs money to store. Absurd!

  6. Thank you for the article. However, if a person does not take possession of physical gold and silver, they don’t own it. Paper promises of gold and silver (ETFs especially) are just that… promises. Others can default and not deliver it to you when you wish.
    And the gold price has been manipulated downward for many years through the use of derivatives, as proven by Bill Murphy and gata.org.

  7. Andrew

    The price of gold is subject to speculative pressure like any other asset class. There’s been no corresponding inflation to justify the run-up of +150% over the past 5 years. Folks would be well advised to look at the historical prices and ask if we are in a “gold bubble” right now.

    Also, a dollar-cost averaging approach would involve buying a fixed dollar amount of gold each month, not a fixed number of gold coins (which isn’t averaging anything).

  8. I’d start by traveling back in time about 10 years…

  9. It is possible to make money buying and selling gold for short term gains, the same as it is with FOREX. But it is not for beginners as you need a lot of experience. The big players can cause the prices to rise or fall at their whim so even if you know about the trading charts and what to look for you could still make losses.
    William

  10. Who wrote this, Glenn Beck? Gold bullion in your basement is not an investment. It’s expensive to ship, expensive to insure, expensive to store. Basically, it’s evidence that you’re a loon. Do you also have a cache of MREs and semiautomatic weapons for when Obama turns the US into a Communist Islamic Fascist Dictatorship? Did you stock up on dehydrated water?

    Owning gold or gold-based ETFs may be a decent hedge against inflation, but honestly, inflation is pretty much the least of our worries right now. And you’d still be better off with, say, TIPS (Treasury Inflation Protected Securities).

    As to the whole “fiat currency” thing, look into the history of the gold standard: it’s often, rightly, described as a barbaric relic of the middle ages. A currency that floats is a currency that can be managed, and which can be used to moderate the effects of booms and busts…. I agree that it may be steered well or poorly but that’s way better than pegging it to some shiny metal dug out of the earth so that it it cannot be steered at all.

    Mint’s a great application, but you’d have a hard time finding writers who offer worse money advice. Is the next piece “Rent-To-Own: What a Great Idea!”

  11. Seems like everyone thinks the fundamentals of this article are flawed but let’s throw some more wood onto the fire! The gold mining process is the most ecologically destructive mining process in existance. The only way to mine gold is strip mining with cyanide based solutions which dissolve gold into poisonous cyanide pools from which molecules of gold are leached. Mountains of earth yield mere ounces of gold. Investing in gold contributes to ecological disaster – do the world a favor and invest in less earth hostile commodities please! For more info see new york times article: http://nyti.ms/bNiohT

  12. paul van

    Check out some excellent discussion of gold as an inflation hedge. It sounds like gold is an insurance policy against political shock or systematic breakdown of the financial system.

    http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/2007/02/is-gold-inflation-hedge.html

    Here’s a nugget for you (very compelling):


    * Gold is a poor hedge against major inflations.
    * Gold appreciates in operational wealth in major deflations.
    * Gold is an ineffective hedge against yearly commodity price increases.
    * Nevertheless, gold does maintain its purchasing power over long periods of time.

    The intriguing aspect of this conclusion is that it is not because gold eventually moves toward commodity prices but because commodity prices move toward gold.

    There is also some discussion of silver. You can easily scoop up physical silver in the form of tubes of Canadian Maples and American Eagles on ebay.

  13. Good article Kevin.The fundamental thesis of your article is sound. I too use physical gold as insurance; and a disciplined effort just like any other savings plan will get you far. I started buying gold back when I was between jobs when it was $12/gram in ’04. When I got regular work the next year I bought monthly. Nice insurance in light of the fact that the value of the US$ has decreased 67% compared to when I started to buy gold.

  14. If you want to buy some gold buy Canadian gold coins, the Maple Leaf gold coin has the highest purity in the world of any gold coins due to the extra purification step (using chlorine, very tricky and dangerous!). Some Maple Leaf gold coins are 99.999% pure compared to other gold coins produced by other countries most of which are only about 90% pure.

  15. Great information! Super informative. Thanks for explaining this in black and white. Some people just get so amped up on the get rich quick scheme they end up losing in the long run by not paying attention to small details. I hope this will help others as much as it helped me!

  16. I would be very careful about investing in Gold traded ETF’s as it is paper gold and when things really heat up in the gold market, I doubt these types of funds will have the actual gold as they say they do.

    Following is quoted from
    John Embry: Chief Investment Strategist – Sprott Asset Management

    JOHN EMBRY: I think the key thing I am watching is the unfolding saga with respect to paper gold. There are some very interesting developments that I am not at liberty to discuss at this point going on, on this front. And I thnk as this becomes more obvious to people, I think an awful lot of individuals and institutions that hold ETFs, pooled gold accounts, gold certificates are going to probably start to feel very uncomfortable about what they own. And, if they start moving in the direction of owning physical gold, or vehicles where the gold is allocated and allotted. I think that will have an outsized impact on the price.